This is probably one of the nicest, most clean Airbnb’s I’ve ever stayed at! The house looks just like the photos - seriously it’s stunning! Rachael was great and quick with any responses I needed! The only “complaint” if I had one is that the water has the strongest sulfur smell- but I know that’s not out of the norm for well water and Rachael does as much as possible for it, but it was crazy strong. I’d recommend this place to anyone!
February 2026
We just had the most wonderful girls birthday celebration weekend at Rachael's amazing home. It was so beautiful, the space was more than we could have asked for. The views were amazing and the house was spotless. This was my fourth trip to the finger lakes and this place was the best of all. The kitchen was a dream and we had a private chef come in and cook us an amazing dinner. The wineries were so close and the town close by was so cute! This was truly a wonderful weekend with so many great memories. I would recommend this place to anyone.
February 2026
We had the best time at Rachael's property. The place was so beautiful and clean, and the views were amazing. <br/>We had 8 moms fit more than comfortably in all the beds with room to spare.<br/>The kitchen was seriously beautiful too. Zero complaints - would recommend to anyone!
February 2026
The house is gorgeous and Rachael is a fantastic host! We loved just spending time there - enjoying the view, the hot tub, and the incredible kitchen. There are a ton of wineries within a short drive. Rachael is very accommodating and went above and beyond to give us a great experience!
February 2026
Booked The Barn at Keuka Lake for my sister's bachelorette weekend in April. Despite the weather being cold and rainy, we had so much fun! Plenty of space for all 11 of us, the kitchen/dining area was GORGEOUS, and it had a beautiful view of the lake. Rachael was super helpful in suggesting places to go, both locally and when we had themed nights to go out places a little farther away. We visited a local winery at Rachael's suggestion, and it did not disappoint! She answered all of our questions quickly and checked in multiple times to see how things were going and if we needed anything. Highly recommend!
February 2026
Rachael’s place was very nice and she was very responsive if we had any questions. Would definitely recommend this place for families or an adult wine tour.
February 2026
We had our annual girls weekend at Athena Barn and had a great time. Plenty of space for the 10 of us and a beautiful location. Rachel was very responsive and I would recommend The Barn.
February 2026
Rachael was very responsive when you needed to get a hold of her and super friendly! Our group had a great time staying at one of her properties.
February 2026
Had a great stay! Would stay again!
February 2026
Beautiful space in a beautiful location! We loved sitting outside overlooking the lake.
February 2026
Great stay and location right in town! Very accommodating host and answered all my questions promptly.
February 2026
The place was amazing for my brothers bachelor party
February 2026
Place was wonderful and Rachael was great to work with. Very accommodating.
February 2026
We absolutely loved our stay at this converted barn on Keuka Lake! The house is gorgeous! It’s spacious, updated, and full of charm, with a huge kitchen and lots of open areas where we could all hang out together. The lake view is breathtaking, and between the hot tub, fire pit, and games, there was never a shortage of things to do. It felt private and peaceful, yet it was super easy to find with plenty of parking for everyone. Our host Rachel was wonderful! She’s very communicative and welcoming, which really made the whole experience even better. We left with such great memories and would come back in a heartbeat!
February 2026
We stayed here for a bachelorette weekend. The home is absolutely stunning— the views, location and design exceeded expectations. It was peaceful and spacious, and the host was polite and provided great local suggestions. The area had recently experienced a dry spell (reportedly the driest two months on record), and unfortunately, the water pressure was extremely low. With 10 women, it became difficult to shower. One day after hiking Watkins Glen, we had to cancel our dinner reservations, because it just wasn’t possible to be ready in time. The TV didn’t work, and while we knew we needed to bring our own propane, it ended up being a big inconvenience— especially with no on-call support (host is not local/no handy man) & safety concerns around guests handling it. Communication was only via messaging. A quick phone call from the host would have helped resolve some issues faster. Overall, a beautiful property, but a few improvements to amenities and support would make it a top-tier stay.
February 2026
Just a few minutes outside downtown Hammondsport and with a view of the lake. Our group enjoyed the large kitchen and wonderful outdoor area to relax. <br/>Having outdoor games and a hot tub was fun for our kids. Also, plenty of seating at the large dining table and kitchen island.
February 2026
The barn was absolutely beautiful. Our entire group was blown away. Rachael was quick to respond, helpful, and gave local recommendations. I will absolutely be returning to this place!
February 2026
We had an amazing time at The Barn on Keuka! It was absolutely stunning, both inside and out. Rachel was an excellent host with great communication. I will definitely recommend this place to others!
February 2026
Had the best stay here for a girls trip! A lot to do in the area and at the home! Our host was extremely responsive and helpful, and I will 100% be staying again! Thank you for a beautiful experience!
February 2026
Our party visited for a long weekend and it was just what we were looking for! A perfect spot for a large group looking to have a wonderful time in a remote location with beautiful views while still remaining close to local attractions.
February 2026
We had an awesome weekend! The place and view were both beautiful! Very close to the local breweries, wineries and restaurants! Highly recommend and would definitely stay here again!<br/>Rachael was an amazing host!
February 2026
Rachael is so responsive and a wonderful host! We absolutely loved the place and it looks exactly as pictured. It was clean, beautiful and had the best view of the lake!
February 2026
This was our first time into the Finger Lakes and it did not disappoint! The house and location were gorgeous and the photos of this place are accurate. It is within minutes of several wineries and about 10 minutes from town and the local beach. We came for my bachelorette party and 9 of us stayed comfortably. My only "criticism" is that I do feel that sleeping 12 there as the listing says the house could, would be a bit tight. But overall, it was great and would stay again. Rachael was awesome. You can tell she really loves this area and is very invested in wanting her guests to have a good time. She was very responsive to my questions and was proactive providing necessary information for check-in and check out. She also made sure to check in with us during our stay to make sure we had everything we needed, and made some great recommendations about wineries and restaurants in the area. She also provides a guide of the area on her page. Will definitely be visiting the area again. :)
February 2026
Rachael has an absolutely beautiful space and it’s clear that it was designed very intentionally. We loved the kitchen, the overall layout and spaciousness of the house, and the view! There were unique decor items and custom wood pieces throughout, including the huge dining table. <br/>Great location, house, and host! We’d definitely stay again!
February 2026
Beautiful home to host a bachelorette for a long weekend! Clean, open spaces with beautiful natural sunlight and thoughtful decor. Lots to do around the house with games and outdoor amenities of the hottub and some yard games! Rachael was quickly responsive when we had a small issue with the water pressure, but it was very understandable for well-water and she was more than accommodating to help us. 10/10 would recommend to any group!
February 2026
This is our second year for a family reunion at the Barn at Keuka and we’ve already booked for next year! The house is very roomy and functional. There is plenty of space for group activities or if individuals want some private space. The outdoor spaces are very accessible and the kitchen is well equipped for preparing large meals. The Barn on Keuka has become part of our family’s traditions and memories. Thank you Rachael!
February 2026
This was the perfect house and location for my family and I. The views at the house are stunning, there were plenty of games at the house to keep us entertained. The hot tub was an added value for us and the fire fit was amazing at night. The house was super clean and the host communicated extremely well. I would say if you have more than 5 cars at the house parking may be an issue.
February 2026
We had the most beautiful stay at Rachael’s place for our first time at the Finger Lakes. She was super responsive to any questions we had. The location was close to the town in Hammondsport. The wine tour with lightning limo was amazing! 10/10 experience
February 2026
We absolutely loved the Airbnb! The place was gorgeous, the pictures were accurate, and Rachael was super communicative and helpful. It’s the perfect place to host a getaway with friends or family and the views were gorgeous. It’s very peaceful and quiet as well. I would absolutely recommend it.
February 2026
